PDA

View Full Version : Need Digital Competition Monitor specs



Christine_Walsh-Newton
10-26-2012, 08:48 PM
Hello - Print chair here trying to find out the monitor specs required at districts. That information used to be in the Jury Chairman's Manual, but does not appear in the 2011 version.

Please help - thank you.

Sarah_Johnston
10-28-2012, 07:26 PM
PPA will ship and calibrate the monitors. The entry specs are in the rules. Did you need anything else?

Rick_Massarini
10-28-2012, 09:51 PM
Sarah,
I've spoke with Christine when I signed her up to help staff the ASP booth, and she is looking for the specs that are used at the Districts to use in calibrating a monitor (or a set of monitors if they can get a set) for their state competition. I have the specs that Ron gave me written down in one of my notebooks but can't put my hands on it right now. If he is available can you have him repost the specs. I'm still looking for my notes to send the info to Christine.

Christine - here's what I have found - my notebook is still MIA...
================================================== =====

VIEWING CONDITONS FOR IMAGE REVIEW
Prints – Tungsten lighting, 3100K, EV8 (ISO 100, f/16@ 1 sec.)
Digital Files – Monitor Settings, D65, 120 cd/m2, 2.20 gamma

These are the current specs for the monitors and the competition lighting. Hope this helps to answer your question.
posted by
Michael E. Timmons
M.Photog.Cr., F-ASP

================================================== ======

http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop-monitors/pa301w-bk-sv

link from Ron Nichols re: monitors used at the IPC

================================================== =======

The monitors that are currently used at the IPC are:
NEC Multisync LCD 3090WQXi
These are last year's version of the monitors described in the NEC link above

================================================== =======

Sarah_Johnston
10-29-2012, 04:30 PM
Calibrating should be the same as for members preping their images. There is a tutorial video on the site for that.

Christine_Walsh-Newton
11-02-2012, 03:58 AM
Thank you for the info - Rick is correct, I was wanting to replicate as closely as possible the affiliated digital judging setup for a state-level conference we are having this weekend.

Ed_Sharp
01-17-2014, 05:44 PM
I noticed that some of the Spectraview monitors advertise a feature called AmbiBright". Does anyone have any experience with this feature and if it does what it promises? It almost seems like it could be a bad thing if it is not 100% accurate when it compensates to a monitor correction based on the ambient lighting.


AmbiBright?
Automatically adjusts the backlight depending on the brightness of ambient lighting conditions. It also tells the monitor to enter power saving mode whenever the ambient lighting falls below a predetermined value (like when lights are shut off at the end of the day), which can significantly reduce energy consumption.

Rick_Massarini
01-21-2014, 02:30 AM
I wonder if that feature can be turned off on the monitor? A monitor changing it's brightness wouldn't be a good thing at a competition. That might work for the casual computer user, but for those of us who are pulling color and adjusting files based on our monitor image a fluctuating brightness level would not be good.

Ed_Sharp
01-21-2014, 12:22 PM
It looks like the 30 inch monitor they use at IPC may have that feature, it is listed under the specifications. If the room's ambient lighting was consistent I guess it wouldn't have to compensate as much, do they have guidelines for the best ambient lighting for viewing the monitors? Hopefully, it is a feature that can be bypassed if desired.

It seems like a smaller version of the monitor they use at IPC might be a good choice to work with for photographers looking to create acurate files/prints.

I have always had a very hard time getting the right density of my prints/files to be WYSIWYG with my current monitor. If it looks perfect on my monitor, it will print darker than that. I calibrate with an ione display2, and my colors seem good, but I have always struggled with print densities. Maybe it has to do with the limitations of my monitor or my current viewing conditions, I just have a dell 1907fp monitor (http://www.dell.com/downloads/emea/products/snp/UltraSharp%201907FP_%20EN.pdf),in the near future would like to get a better monitor and set it up with optimum viewing conditions for working. I am currently not viewing my monitor under a daylight bulb, which I imagine does not help either.


I remember Andrew Rodney had some great posts here in the past on this topic. I looked up one of his articles on soft proffing from PPA magazine and linked it below.


http://www.ppmag.com/reviews/200411_rodneycm.pdf
The ambient light in the studio where the display resides is also critical. Not only should the ambient light be rather dim, but also as close to daylight balanced as possible. No ambient lighting should fall on the face of the display. Bright colors on
adjacent walls can greatly affect color perception. Ideally, the display luminance and the light box will be the brightest two
objects in the environment

Here is another one of his articles from Luminous landscape that talks about the process of getting a good print.
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tutorials/why_are_my_prints_too_dark.shtml

cat_broderick
02-04-2014, 01:51 PM
Bumping this old thread up. PPA specs 30" NEC monitor. If that particular monitor is not available what are states using for comp?

arodney
02-21-2014, 01:25 AM
AmbiBright can be disabled and should be. But why the questions about this display? Are folks assuming that what they see will match whatever this display is producing too? Not likely, not unless you are using the same display system, instrument for calibration and calibration software. If you use a differing system, but follow the same calibration targets, you might be close, might not. YMMV.

Ed_Sharp
02-21-2014, 12:53 PM
I only speak for myself, but my main reason for wanting to learn more about the system was that I am trying to get the best monitor I can and assumed that the one they used for print comp would be one of the best. I did also assume that it would be pretty close to what they see at IPC and didn't take any of the other factors into consideration. I assumed they were using the Spectraview software and puck, but didn't think about the other variables.

I have been looking at the smaller sister to this monitor,the new PA272W-SV (or the discontinued version NEC PA271W with close out pricing). If building a computer system that was intending to use one of these monitors, what considerations should be kept in mind when selecting a graphic card or other components? I had been considering using an EVGA GeForce GTX 760 (http://www.evga.com/Products/Product.aspx?pn=02G-P4-2765-KR) for the video card, but the machine is being built for photo editing so any suggestions about what to look for in a card or other components would be greatly appreciated. I know the card should be able to take advantage of Adobe's Mercury Graphics Engine and have enough resolution for the display, have the right connections for the display, are there any other important things to keep in mind?

Thanks for the clarification re:AmbiBright

Sorry for taking this thread off topic, but hopefully the question I am asking will apply to creating the type of accurate viewing the OP was looking for.