PDA

View Full Version : Think your critique was a little hard?



Peter_Bauer
08-02-2008, 06:07 PM
Any time you start feeling sorry for yourself, thinking that a judge's or colleagues critique of your work was bit too tough, read the New York Times review of the movie "America the Beautiful" (emphasis added):

---------------
August 1, 2008
What You See

By JEANNETTE CATSOULIS
Clueless, directionless and altogether pointless, “America the Beautiful” will outrage only those who have spent the last 50 years in suspended animation. Paddling in the shallow end of a very deep pool, the writer and director Darryl Roberts bumbles his way through a hodgepodge of impressions about our national quest for physical perfection before suggesting — wait for it — that real beauty is on the inside. I feel enlightened already.

Stuffed with empty sound bites from the likes of Jessica Simpson and Paris Hilton, this fabulously inept documentary aims much of its ire at the beauty industry’s purported tyranny of impressionable young women. Ignoring writers who have spent their careers studying this issue (including Jean Kilbourne and her pioneering video series, “Killing Us Softly”), Mr. Roberts conducts embarrassingly naïve and occasionally creepy interviews with young girls concerned about their body image. Though what we can learn from a close-up of a 12-year-old model’s naked thigh is not precisely clear.

Displaying an astonishing degree of ignorance about his chosen subject (“What’s a six-pack?”), Mr. Roberts zigzags from eating disorders to music videos to Eve Ensler chatting about — what else? — designer vaginas, without drawing breath or conclusions. If he had, he might have noticed that the tragic story of that 12-year-old model offered all the material his movie needed.
---------------

Ouch!

Pete

Liz_Vance
08-02-2008, 07:16 PM
Wow... those are some fantastic criticisms.

Shark sandwich?

:)